shakuhatchi music painting

Can We Hear a Painting?

Exploring Music in Visual Art

Can we hear a painting? The idea of paintings creating music has captivated artists for centuries. While some might scoff at the notion, for those open to artistic exploration, the question becomes: how can we translate the emotions and sounds of music into visual art? And what would be even more exciting: can you create images that have a musical effect on the viewer?

I am pretty sure that if there was a need, a computer program could be written that would convert images into music. Perhaps we will live to see it. Until then, we will have to rely on our imagination.

Early Attempts to Capture Music

Historical evidence suggests this pursuit stretches back millennia. For example, certain rock paintings seem to embody the essence of music and dance [1].

cave paintung with musicians
A section of Cederberg’s rupestre painting, digitally enhanced to enhance the colors red-orange. © Neil Rusch (link)

Throughout art history, countless painters have tackled this challenge. Recently, I was struck by the surrealist interpretations of Mozart’s music by Roberto Matta in a Vienna exhibition [2].

Roberto Matta Exhibition at Bank Austria Kunstforum in Vienna

Personal Experiments: From Opera to Ambient

My ongoing project, “The Magic Sea,” explores the interplay between music and visual art. Inspired by Richard Wagner’s operas, particularly his concept of a Gesamtkunstwerk (total artwork), I began by translating “Rheingold” into a painting I had presented before. This initial effort focused on capturing the mood and world at the bottom of the Rhine, where the Rhine daughters guard the gold.

Rheingold painting by friedrich zettl
Richard Wagner’s Rheingold

A subsequent work titled “Overture” delves deeper into the concept of translating sound into image. Here the audience imagines that they are sitting in an opera house and the tension is rising as the conductor raises his baton and the curtain gradually rises.

magic sea opera opening scene

Challenges and New Directions

Further explorations within the “Ring” cycle proved the difficulty of expressing music through an expressionist style, especially with Wagner’s complex compositions.

Valkyrie painting
Stage design for Richard Wagner’s The Valkyrie

I have varied my attempt a little and tried to capture the essence of Bruckner’s 9th Symphony. While the green tones capture a sense of Bruckner’s music’s complexity, power and compactness, the work remains largely descriptive.

painting after anton bruckner
Anton Bruckner’s 9th Symphony

Finding Harmony Through Reduction

I think I’ve already mentioned that I tried to pay attention to the (time) space between the tones as part of mindfulness exercises. This exercise sparked a new direction. Asian music, with its focus on transient tones and silence, seemed a more suitable source of inspiration. Shakuhachi flute music [4] exemplifies this attempt quite well. (music sample)

shakuhatchi music painting
Hear a Painting? The sound of Shakuhachi music

To return to Western music, I studied Bach’s “Music Book for Anna Magdalena Bach” and captured the childlike innocence of this music in a piece that could easily serve as an album cover. Bach’s perfect harmony, sparkling tones, and depth in simplicity have not lost their charm to this day.

Bach painting
Notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach

Embracing Complexity and Modernity

Taking this approach further, I tackled the work of Arvo Pärt, particularly “Spiegel im Spiegel”, his most frequently played work. The aim was to capture both the content and form of the music within the painting.

Arvo Pärt Mirror in the Mirror painting
Spiegel im Spiegel (Mirror in the mirror) Arvo Pärt, 1978

While some sounds seem to me to be floating, I see the sounds of the xylophone as jumping. Only when they are in the air do they tell their story.

xylophone music drawing
playing with the tones of a xylophone

In a previous article, “Emptiness, Space, and Depth,” I introduced similar monochrome works from this series. Today, I revisit a piece inspired by Brian Eno, a contemporary musician who frequently influences my work. This final painting attempts to capture the sound of ambient music during a live performance (My Life in the Bush of Ghosts by Brian Eno and David Byrne).

David Byrne music
Brian Eno – Live Concert

The Experiment Continues

This exploration of music and painting is an ongoing journey. Thank you for joining me on this exploration of the fascinating connections between these two art forms!

footnotes

[1] A section of the Cederberg rock painting was digitally enhanced to enhance the colors red-ochre. © Neil Rusch. This processing helped to emphasize the character of the music.

[2] Roberto Matt exhibition at the Bank Austria Forum, February 24, 2024 – June 2, 2024

[3] Wagner’s idea of ​​the Gesamtkunstwerk (total work of art) has fascinated me since my youth and still influences a large part of my work today. The same applies to his method of depicting people and objects in his operas in themes.

[4] The primary genres of shakuhachi music are: Honkyoku (traditional, solo) Sankyoku (ensemble, with koto and shamisen) Shinkyoku (new music composed for shakuhachi and koto, commonly post-Meiji period compositions influenced by Western music)


ShopsFriedrichZettl.com – Saatchiart . MediaBlog – Youtube – Instagram

Comments

69 responses to “Can We Hear a Painting?”

  1. Cindy Georgakas avatar

    Thought provoking and I could feel the beat through the pulse of my heart and body looking at each picture and reading your words, Friedrich🙏🏼💃🏻❤️

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      How kind of you, Cindy! I’m so happy to hear it. Sometimes I’m not sure whether I’ve really managed to express what I intended. Enjoy your muse! 💃🏻❤️

      1. Cindy Georgakas avatar

        You’re so very welcome, Friedrich! I can assure you that you always get your message across. Thanks so much my friend.. I’m hoping she appears💃🏻💕❤️🙏🏼

  2. Dominik Alexander avatar

    I’m not a huge Bruckner listener but your green velvet painting sounds good to me! Also like the Brian Eno one.

    Adding a thought to your great post, I think you can definitely see sound in paintings through colour and movement. Would be interesting to get a few musical interpretations for one specific painting. Wouldn’t be surprised if they kinda sound similar.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you, Dominik! For a long time, Bruckner wasn’t that interesting to me either. He worked not far from where I was born and after a visit to the St. Florian monastery, where I was able to hear the Bruckner organ live, he took on more color for me.
      Yes, it is certainly possible to turn images into music. There is just no great commercial benefit to be seen.

  3. graysummers avatar

    You expressed your investigations here perfectly. As a musician I found it an extremely interesting read. Brian Eno was an interesting inclusion for immediate thoughts as I have a few of his albums. And when listening to his and others’ music during Mindful meditation, a picture or object replaces mind imagery to enhance the experience. This due to having Aphantasia. No mind’s eye. I cannot sit next to that river scene and ‘imagine’ watching a leaf float by and put my worrisome thoughts upon it, to allow them to float away. So I do require a ‘hard copy’ to focus upon. And a painting that flows and moves in relationship to the music heard? Perfect. The synergy of music, art and meditation is a perfect holistic therapy. As ever, your art is outstanding. Thank you.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      You are very kind, Gray, and I am very happy that you can do something with my modest work! Regarding your example of the leaf flowing past you on a stream, there is a very fitting story from the Tang period in China. You probably know it. Yes, I think that many of us perceive music in very different ways. Just as we see abstract images differently. Or interpret certain poems differently, are addressed by them or feel nothing.

      I think that with mindfulness exercises you should simply expect nothing at all. And thank you for your compliment!

      1. graysummers avatar

        When a nurse, myself and two other nurses taught a therapy course, in our local community, regarding Mindfulness inclusions for healing. The NHS actually supported the practice. It was interesting talking to others that attended as to how they approached their own Mindful practices. You have given fantastic guidance here too. So thank you.

      2. graysummers avatar

        And I will search for the Tang story too. I haven’t heard it. Thanks for the mention.

      3. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        This link should help you (2nd paragraph) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lantingji_Xu

      4. graysummers avatar

        Thank you. A good read. The part in translation stating ‘Although without the accompaniment of music, the wine and poem reciting are sufficient for us to exchange our feelings.’? For musicians, I believe there would be music presence in the melodic noise of the passing stream. Thank you for the link.

      5. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Oh yes, of course! And since Chinese is a tonal language, the recitation of the poems was something like a speech-singing. In classical Chinese, the term “singing” was also used for the recitation of a poem.

      6. graysummers avatar

        And I do ‘sing’ Mantra’s too. The Medicine Buddha long version mantra especially. Again thank you for these insights. Very much appreciated.

      7. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        You are more than welcome! I have suggested a link that tells the story of the leaves and the stream in an abridged version. There is something very wise in this meeting of poets like Li Bai, Du Fu and friends. I hope you like it!

  4. gkazakou avatar

    Ein Eintrag, den ich beim schnellen Durchsehen sehr faszinierend finde und genau studieren werde. Danke!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Vielen herzlichen Dank! Nun, es sind vielleicht nur unzureichende Ergebnisse, aber der Gedanke gefaellt mir! Schoenes Wochenende!

  5. swabby429 avatar

    Your examples today remind me of the amorphous and geometrical shapes I see during extended periods of music listening at home. I close the eyes and allow the psychedelic part of my imagination to manifest itself.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much! I’m very happy about that, because that’s what I meant. I’ve seen many examples of pictures that deal with music, but only a few capture the “feeling of music”, the transcendent. I may not have managed it either, but I tried 🙂

  6. worldphoto12 avatar

    BUON WEEK-END

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you! The same to you! Enjoy it!

      1. worldphoto12 avatar

        GRAZIE ZETTI 🙂

  7. Stan Stewart avatar

    A truly inspiring view into your creative process. Thank you!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much, Stan! Have a great weekend!

  8. J M Negi avatar

    We certainly can… provided we have a heart to that beat. Very nice read, sincere thanks.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much! Yes, I also think it is always a question of whether we have the right heart. Art of any kind always goes from heart to heart.

  9. Kristallina avatar

    Was für en spannender Gedanke. Ich liebe klassische Musik und Deine Beschreibungen haben mich tatsächlich Musik hören lassen. Werde alles gleich noch einmal ganz langsam lesen. Schönes Wochenende!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Wie mich das freut! Herzlichen Dank! Dir auch ein entspanntes und erfuelltes Wochenende! LG f

  10. Muddy Brook Studio, Pejj Nunes avatar

    I know I do, I love to climb into a painting and ride around. There is no other way to see everything. The mind solves paintings like they are puzzles. The mind relies on all senses to do so. It relies on imagination and experiences had.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you! That’s great and you’ve hit the nail on the head! That’s why in Chinese paintings there is always a point where you “enter” the painting and a path that you walk through. I often use this too. Or, as with the stage design for the Valkyrie, I create a kind of pull, a tunnel, that lets you immerse yourself more easily in the painting.

  11. Ashley avatar

    Fascinating! When I’m reading poems or prose, there are some pieces that do sing, that clearly bring music to my ears! I believe that all the different expressions of art, written, musical, visual, all are interconnected & that some people are more attuned than others! Wonderful paintings, Friedrich & whilst my hearing is not as good as it used to be, I appreciate the rhythm & beat of your paintings. 😊

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you Ashley for your kind words! Yes, I see it exactly the same way, they are all connected. Wagner saw it that way too – only his libretti were a bit, hmm, strange :).
      I’m trying to put the whole thing under a philosophical umbrella, which should give some of the works a broader meaning. Well, the journey is the destination, as the saying goes! All the best!

  12. Martha Kennedy avatar

    I especially love the Rheingold painting. I love the opera, and your painting captures what I hear.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much, Martha! I actually wanted to start a larger series of music for operas. But then I realized that only Wagner and possibly Strauss would be suitable for me. Bajazzo or Falstaff? Not really. I wish you a pleasant, relaxing summer! All the best!

      1. Martha Kennedy avatar

        Thank you, Friedrich! Siegfried’s Rheinfahrt — which I randomly heard on the car radio driving home from school (teaching) one night — brought me to Wagner and I’m so happy it did. I felt as if I’d waited all my life to hear that. Have a lovely summer, too.

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        For me it was Parsifal. I had to stay in bed, remembered a little grass I still had for rainy days and off I went….😄

      3. Martha Kennedy avatar

        I didn’t even know what it was when I heard it! There’s a riff of it in the film Goethe! It ran and ran and ran through my mind. I happened to hear it again and learned what it was. ❤️

      4. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        It is fascinating how and why we came across certain music that then became of central importance in our lives. In the case of Bach, it was a performance by Friedrich Gulda at an alternative music festival. The Well-Tempered Clavier was on the programme. Guests of honour and “select audience” in the good seats, the few long-haired people in the cheap ones at the back. Then Gulda came and maltreated the piano with a knife and fork. The haute volee soon fled. And when the rows had thinned out, he played Bach. And my life has been different since then.

      5. Martha Kennedy avatar

        ❤️

  13. Edith avatar

    Friedrich, das ist einfach gigantisch. Mir ging es schon immer so – nur anders herum – ich sah und sehe, wenn ich Wagner oder Bach höre, Farben, die sich harmonisch bewegen. Gerade bei Bach, über den ich ja meine Hochschulabschlussarbeit schrieb, bin ich mir da gaaanz sicher, das seine Musik in Bildern lebt und leben kann. Und bei ihm ist ja typisch, wenn Zeit drängte, er einen Auftrag bekam, welcher schnell erledigt werden musste, dann funktionierte er ein stilles Werk in ein lautes. Es ist ganz einfach herauszuhören – manchmal hatte er sehr viele Orchestermitglieder, dann waren es wieder sehr wenige, aber seinen Werken merkte man das nicht an.
    Grad jubelt mein Herz, indem ich deine Bestätigung verinnerliche… Und in deinen Gemälden finde ich auch Wagner. Die Farben stimmen total. Also kann ich es auch anders herum, lächel…
    Einen feinen Sonnensonntag wünsche ich dir von ganzem Herzen
    mit einer Umarmung aus der Ferne,
    von mir mit lieben Grüßen.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Vielen herzlichen Dank, liebe Edith, für Deine freundlochen Worte und Deine Bestaetigung! Es hätte mich fast gewundert, haettest Du mit meinen Beispielen nichts anzufangen gewusst. Bach ist ohnehin so groß, dass man sich ihm schwer naehern kann. Aber bei Wagner, so umstritten er auch sein mag, ist es das Konzept des Gesamtkunstwerkes, das mit seit Jahrzehnten begleitet. So versuche ich auch des Öfteren, Poetik und eben auch, versuchsweise mit Musik in meine Malerei einzubringen. Und natürlich philosophische Gedanken.
      Ich bin dann doch ueberrascht, dass so viele Leser meine Bemuehungen nachvollziehen bzw, teilen koennen. Aber Du kennst das ja vom Schreiben….

      Auch Dir eine freundliche Umarmung und die besten Gruesse und Wuensche

      1. Edith avatar

        Du Lieber, diese Menschen haben wie wir, offene Sinne. Und es genügt oftmals ein kleiner Anstupser, und sie finden sich darin wieder. Ja, Bach war einfach gigantisch!!! Beethoven sagte mal über ihn: Nicht Bach, Meer sollte er heißen! Und du sprichst es an, Wagner kann man nur im Gesamtkonzept betrachten. Dieses Für und Wider, was über ihm wie ein Schwert hängt, finde ich sowas von daneben. Er hat in dieser Zeit gelebt, wurde durch Menschen, die man jetzt negieren möchte, gefördert. Ohne sie gäbe es nicht DIESEN Wagner.
        Und, weil du das Schreiben mit ins Feld ziehst. auch aus Texten wird Musik und anders rum ebenso. NUR – Musik in Farben auszudrücken, das hat was, das ist Besonders, damit öffnet man Herzen. Und das schaffst du, und hast es geschafft.

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Ja, diese ideologische Keule hat mir Wagner einige Zeit vermiest. Vor allem dann die unsaeglichen Inzenierungen mit Natsi-Kostümen. Peinliches Niveau …. Aenhlich dann auch bei Furtwaengler. Inzwischen scheint er ja rehabilitiert.
        Aber zum Rechtsruck heute faellt keinem ein vernuenftiger Satz ein.

  14. Dawn Pisturino avatar

    Love these!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much! I am happy to hear. All the best!

  15. James Viscosi avatar

    I look at those, I imagine the sound of wings …

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you James! Yes, the light, floating or flying is very important to me. If I counteract it with something heavy in the picture, the “flying” should be stronger and more dynamic.Very interesting!

  16. MobsterTiger avatar

    Cool!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much!

      1. MobsterTiger avatar

        You’re very welcome my dear friend! #GoodWorks

  17. Cyber Brust avatar
    Cyber Brust

    ❤️

  18. Fashion Boutique avatar

    I think we can

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏 I’m quite surprised by the many positive confirmations.

  19. Fashion Boutique avatar

    Thanks for the information! Very enlightening.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much for your kind words!

  20. PhreakyHealer avatar

    This is so interesting! All forms of art are connected to our feelings. I understand your study and I am intrigues by it. The way the pictures are made really do look like the way the music makes me feel. You mentioned the music from other cultures. Yes- I feel different things and imagine different things when I hear different instruments. An instrumental song takes me so much further into feeling as well compared to a song with words. Very cool, I want to take more time to look more into your work! Thanks for sharing

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much! I’m pleased to hear that you like my modest work! Yes, music is fascinating, even for me, as I played an instrument myself for many years. In my opinion, music has been treated far too little in painting up to now. At least not in the way I imagine. All the best!

  21. Wolfpup avatar

    Beautiful.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much!

  22. Fashion Boutique avatar

    Nice story ❤️

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏

  23. Isabel avatar
    Isabel

    This is so interesting! in my opinion everything is connected with how we can express ourselfs. I love every art piece showcased because you can really feel and understand how the artist was feeling with every look. I love how you explain everything in detail, because it really showcases the amount of understanding not many know about expressing ourselves with art. ❤

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much for your kind words. I am glad you liked it. All the best! Friedrich

  24. spotlightchoices.com-C. Wilson avatar

    Amazing how you have taken sound and rhythm and the creativity of music and created beautiful works of art!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much for your kind words about my experiments! I am pleased that you can to them. All the best! Friedrich

      1. spotlightchoices.com-C. Wilson avatar

        You are welcome!

  25. Stardust avatar
    Stardust

    Super interesting 😍

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you from the bottom of my heart ❤️❤️❤️

  26. lisahawkinsfineart avatar

    Very interesting – beautiful work.❤️

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much for your kind words!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Friedrich Zettl

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading