Meditation of the Zen Master

Final Part and the Climax of the Journey to the Zen Master.

Meditation of the Zen Master: Today, we embark on the third and final part of our journey to the Zen Master. Besides showcasing my artwork, I share key insights into my understanding of Zen. This article covers essential concepts with the help of appropriate images to make these ideas more accessible. If you’re short on time, you can skip to the final image and AI analysis. This summary captures the essence of the series and ties in with my previous articles on Zen and Dao.

Whole article series: part I – part II – part III

In this part of the series, AI will analyze the images, just like before. [1] As I mentioned earlier, this is an experiment and a bit of fun, so it shouldn’t be taken too seriously. The AI has analyzed the works in great detail, but I will only highlight the most important and relevant parts. Above all, I will focus on the sections that illuminate the essence of Zen and Zen meditation.

To warm up and make it easier to get back into the swing of things, let’s start with this one:

1 – The monks come for morning meditation

AI: Zen Monks Gathering for Morning Meditation – A Concise Analysis

“This image, depicting Zen monks engaged in morning meditation, utilizes a minimalist approach with black ink on a stark white background, immediately conveying a sense of peace and introspection. The abstract figures, identifiable as monks through posture and suggested robes, are gathered in a moment of stillness.

Key Observations:

Implied Movement: While the monks are still, the brushstrokes themselves suggest a subtle energy. The texture and direction of the strokes create a sense of dynamism, hinting at the inner movement of meditation, the flow of breath, or even the subtle energies (qi) [2] circulating during practice. The central monk’s robe is noticeably different from the other two, with a clear focal point in the center and a unique flow, almost as if energy is emanating from them.

Visual Simplicity: The stark contrast and limited detail echo the Zen principle of simplicity, drawing attention to the essential: the figures and their meditative state. The composition itself is uncomplicated and direct. The lack of intricate detail draws the viewer in, inviting contemplation.“

Basic Consideration about the Project

I am very pleased that quite a few of my readers found the first two parts engaging. It is in the nature of things that not everyone can like everything, which is of course perfectly fine. However, one aspect that should invite my readers to reflect is the question: How would I approach the topic myself? How can I fundamentally depict something intangible like Zen or meditation? By portraying the smoke of a patchouli incense stick? Just kidding. Which technique should I choose? Which style of presentation? Should I paint flat or emphasize lines? And similar fundamental questions. At what point does the viewer also experience the feeling of Zen? If we come to the conclusion that less is more – how little can it be? Too much is not good, too little is not good – where is the line where our innermost self says “oh”?

2 – Reduction of a landscape to its spiritual essence

In the previous 2 parts of this article, we’ve primarily focused on landscapes. To simplify further and draw closer to Zen, as I perceive it, I’ve created the following work. The goal is to highlight the inherent beauty, power, and natural harmony found in landscapes.

AI: A Reduced Landscape – A Visual Exploration of “Less is More”

This reduced landscape is a powerful meditation on the nature of perception and the essence of Zen aesthetics. It challenges the viewer to engage actively with the artwork, to find meaning in the spaces between the brushstrokes, and to discover the beauty in simplicity. The image is an embodiment of “less is more.” It demonstrates that a few well-chosen marks can evoke a profound sense of place and feeling.

• Fragmentation and Essence: The landscape is fragmented, broken down into its essential components. (…..)
• It provides just enough visual information to trigger the viewer’s recognition of a landscape, but leaves ample room for interpretation. This ambiguity is where the “Zen” feeling emerges – in the space between what is shown and what is perceived, or even felt.

The “oh” moment likely arises when the viewer recognizes the essence of the landscape despite its fragmented form. It’s the moment of connection, where the minimal visual cues trigger a deeper understanding or feeling. The image also poses the question, “When does a landscape stop being a landscape?”

3 – Abstract Beauty and Light – One Step Further

In a next step, we try to let go even more, to use even less “attachment,” and to get closer to the essence of beauty – and light.

It goes without saying that light is not an insignificant matter for a painter. But how do we create “spiritual light“? Because if we try to omit as much as possible and also do not want to cling too much to forms, we have to find something else with which I can create something spiritual in a picture.

AI: This image, born from the intention to “let go even more” and move closer to the “essence of beauty,” pushes the boundaries of abstraction even further than the previous one. It is a powerful visual representation of the process of letting go. It demonstrates that beauty can be found in the most unexpected places, even in abstract forms that defy easy categorization. It’s an invitation to embrace the unknown, to find joy in the present moment, and to appreciate the beauty of imperfection. This image is a testament to the power of non-attachment in artistic creation.

Key Observations:

The Beauty of Imperfection (Wabi-Sabi): [3] This artwork seems to embody the Japanese aesthetic principle of Wabi-Sabi. (……) The rough textures, the undefined forms, and the overall sense of transience are all hallmarks of Wabi-Sabi. (……)

Extreme Abstraction: The forms are even more abstracted than in the previous image. It’s challenging to definitively identify any specific objects or elements of a landscape. This ambiguity invites the viewer to relinquish their preconceived notions of what a “landscape” should look like. This image is a clear departure from traditional representation.

Textural Focus: Texture takes center stage in this artwork. The intricate patterns created by the brushstrokes and the varying densities of ink create a rich tapestry of tactile sensations. (……)

Dynamic Composition: Despite its abstract nature, the composition is dynamic and engaging. The eye is drawn across the image, exploring the interplay of light and shadow, the different textures, and the strategically placed areas of negative space. The composition is generally vertical, although the top right portion features a strong horizontal focus.

Vertical and Horizontal: The image can be divided both vertically and horizontally. The left side is dominated by a large, textured, vertical form that takes up more than 50% of the overall image space. The right side features three smaller elements, two of which are vertical and one horizontal.

Qi – The vital force part of all living entities

Most people are generally familiar with the term “qi,” [2]. We have been reading a lot about this term before on this blog. But it goes much deeper than we usually assume. Similar to taiji-quan: We take pleasure in the graceful movements, and it doesn’t look that difficult either. Only when we practice it ourselves for a long time and ideally have a good teacher, do we gradually penetrate this world. With qigong, it goes even deeper than with taiji-quan, because we cultivate and strengthen our qi, our breath of life. So this is also a meditative act. It’s meditative because the simultaneity of concentrating on our breath, coordinating movements, and feeling the qi demand a lot of mindfulness from us.

Many years ago I climbed one of the sacred mountains in China. (I will elaborate on this in one of my next articles). I practiced in the morning and in the evening, and the experience left a deep impression on me. You stand somewhere high up on a mountain, surrounded by rugged peaks that are even higher, separated by “nothing” and “emptiness” – namely by the white of the morning mist and clouds. But we know that this “nothing” only conceals something – rocks or sparse vegetation.

4: The Qigong Practitioner – A Visual Meditation on Qi Cultivation within the Sacred Landscape

AI: This image is a powerful visual metaphor for the meditative experience and the cultivation of Qi. It transcends a literal depiction of a landscape, inviting the viewer to contemplate the interconnectedness of inner and outer worlds, the power of emptiness, and the vital energy that flows through all things. It’s a beautiful representation of your personal journey and the profound insights gained through your practice.

This image is a beautiful depiction of the harmony between the individual and the environment, the flow of Qi, and the profound connection to nature that can be achieved through dedicated practice. (…..) It is a compelling representation of the journey inward, the essence of spiritual practice. The central figure as a monk (or you) practicing Qigong, becomes a powerful visual representation of Qi cultivation within a sacred landscape, mirroring your own profound experience on the Chinese mountain.

Key Observations with the Practitioner in Focus:

Harmony of Inner and Outer: This image beautifully illustrates the harmony between inner and outer landscapes. The practitioner’s internal cultivation of Qi is mirrored in the external environment, blurring the boundaries between the self and the natural world. This reflects the Taoist principle of interconnectedness and the Zen concept of oneness with nature.

(…….)

Qi Flow Emanating from the Practitioner: With the center-figure identified as a practitioner, the surrounding textures and brushstrokes can be interpreted as Qi flowing outward from him. The dynamic lines and varying densities of ink visually represent the cultivation and circulation of Qi, emanating from the practitioner and interacting with the surrounding landscape. The viewer’s eye is naturally drawn to this figure, highlighting their importance within the scene.

The Mountain as Resonant Space: The abstract mountain forms now take on the role of a resonant space, reflecting and amplifying the Qi cultivated by the practitioner. The landscape becomes an active participant in the practice, mirroring the inner state of the practitioner and creating a harmonious exchange of energy. The mountains almost appear to be responding to the practitioner’s presence.

Emptiness as a Conduit: The white space, representing the “emptiness” or mist you described, acts as a conduit for the flow of Qi between the practitioner and the landscape. It’s not a void, but a space of potentiality and connection, facilitating the exchange of energy.

4a – Variation on Qi Cultivation within the Sacred Landscape

AI: This artwork is a powerful and thought-provoking reinterpretation of traditional Zen aesthetics. By placing the Qigong practitioner at the center, you’ve created a dynamic and engaging composition. This challenges conventional notions of emptiness and highlights the transformative power of inner cultivation. It’s a bold statement about the potential for individuals to become a source of positive energy and to shape their own reality through dedicated practice. This is a truly unique and inspiring piece.

This placement signifies their active role in the cultivation of Qi and their integral connection to the surrounding environment. They are not a passive observer but a dynamic force within the landscape. The figure is more easily identifiable in this iteration, solidifying their importance within the composition.

Features

• Center as Source: Instead of representing emptiness as a void, the center now becomes the source of Qi, emanating outward from the practitioner. The figure’s central position suggests that they are the focal point of this energy, the generator of the dynamic interplay between inner and outer landscapes. The figure is also proportionally much larger than in the previous image. It takes up much more space and solidifying their importance.
• Dynamic Relationship with the Landscape: The abstract mountain forms, while still suggestive of a natural setting, now seem to interact more directly with the practitioner. The lines and textures appear to flow towards and around the figure, as if the landscape itself is responding to the practitioner’s presence and the energy they are cultivating. The mountains almost seem to be leaning in towards the practitioner.
• Reframing Emptiness: This composition challenges the traditional notion that the center must be empty in Zen art. It suggests that emptiness is not merely an absence, but a potentiality that can be filled with focused intention and the dynamic flow of Qi. The practitioner’s presence embodies this potentiality, transforming the center into a source of energy and connection.
• Breaking Convention: By placing the practitioner in the center, you’re making a bold artistic statement. You’re suggesting that the individual, through dedicated practice, can become the still point around which the world revolves, a microcosm of the universe itself. The figure is also facing to the right, which is unusual in traditional depictions, which often have figures facing towards the left.

5 – Meditations

Even before I devoted myself to the actual topic, the meditation of the Zen master, I made a few attempts to abstract meditation itself, to peel it away from the visible and tangible. Little by little, the meditating person took shape. A few attempts were made that initially showed Bodhidharma in front of the rock face. [4]

Bodhidharma’s meditation

AI: This depiction of Bodhidharma’s meditation in front of the rock face is a powerful representation of the Zen concept of perseverance and the pursuit of enlightenment. The abstract forms and stark contrast between black and white create a sense of intensity and focus.

The figure of Bodhidharma, though not explicitly defined, is suggested by the central vertical form, perhaps a suggestion of his unwavering posture during his nine years of meditation. The surrounding strokes and textures could represent the cave or the rock face, embodying the challenges and obstacles on the path to enlightenment.

The emptiness surrounding the figure emphasizes the solitary nature of this spiritual pursuit. It also highlights the inner strength and determination required to overcome distractions and delve into the depths of one’s own being.

The dynamic strokes and textures suggest the inner turmoil and struggles that Bodhidharma may have faced during his meditation. Yet, there’s also a sense of stillness and groundedness, conveying his unwavering commitment to his practice.

This painting invites us to contemplate the dedication and perseverance required to attain enlightenment. It’s a reminder that the path to wisdom is not always easy, but the rewards are immeasurable.

6: The Zen Master in Contemplation – Meditating on the “Form” of “No Form”

Some works in this series were dedicated to the theme of instruction by the Zen Master. And then I had an idea for a small series that I would like to try. Similar to my semi-haiku [5], I want to paint koan.

AI: This image is a powerful visual representation of a core concept in Zen Buddhism. It’s a compelling depiction of the Zen Master’s meditative practice and his exploration of the profound nature of reality. The artwork invites the viewer to contemplate the meaning of “no form” and to consider the limitations of their own perception. It’s a beautiful and thought-provoking piece that captures the essence of the Zen path.

This image presents a more concrete depiction of the Zen Master, seated on the left, engaged in deep meditation. The concept of meditating on the “form” of “no form” introduces a paradoxical element that is central to Zen philosophy.

Key Observations:

• The Zen Master’s Posture: The Zen Master is depicted in a traditional meditative posture, suggesting deep concentration and inner peace. His form is clearly defined, grounding the abstract concept of “no form” in a tangible representation. His posture is mirrored by the figure on the right side of the composition, though the figure on the right is more abstract.
• The “Form” of “No Form”: The right side of the image can be interpreted as the “form” of “no form” that the Zen Master is meditating on. It’s an abstract space, yet it possesses a distinct structure and texture. It suggests that “no form” is not simply an absence, but rather a different kind of presence, a potentiality that is both empty and full. The right side is more abstract and ethereal than the left.
• Interplay of Light and Shadow: The interplay of light and shadow is particularly significant in this image. The Zen Master is illuminated, suggesting that he is a source of enlightenment or insight. The right side is shrouded in shadow, representing the mystery and ineffability of “no form.” The contrast between light and dark emphasizes the duality and interconnectedness of form and emptiness.

6a Variation with Koan

Again, several variants “Instructions from the Zen Master” emerged. And since we’re already experimenting, I thought it would be interesting to look at a koan for some of the works.

A work with a koan for this would look like this:

AI: The Koan:

Before the sun rises, three forms approach the Silent One.

The first carries the weight of mountains, yet leaves no footprints.

The second dances with the wind, yet casts no shadow.

The third is drenched in red, yet remains untouched by water.

The Silent One sits, unmoving, yet encompasses all.

Who are these visitors, and what is the sound of their arrival?

Considerations for Contemplation:

The Sound of Arrival: The final question, “what is the sound of their arrival?” is a classic koan-like element, designed to break down habitual patterns of thought and open the mind to a more intuitive understanding. It is reminiscent of the famous koan, “What is the sound of one hand clapping?” [6]

The Three Forms: The three forms on the left, rendered in abstract strokes, could represent different aspects of the self, different states of mind, or different approaches to enlightenment. Their ambiguous nature invites deep reflection. The form on the left is large and imposing. The central form is tall and thin. The form on the right is smaller and more dynamic, with a prominent splash of red.

Paradoxical Attributes: Each form is described with paradoxical attributes (e.g., carrying weight but leaving no footprints). These paradoxes challenge the logical mind and point towards the limitations of conceptual thinking. They hint at the nature of reality beyond duality.

The Silent One: The Zen Master on the right, the “Silent One,” represents the awakened mind, the embodiment of wisdom and stillness. His presence is both grounded and transcendent. He is facing to the left, an unusual direction in traditional depictions.

The Unasked Question: The koan implicitly asks about the nature of reality, the self, and the path to enlightenment. It invites the practitioner to go beyond the surface appearance of the image and delve into its deeper meaning.

7 – Meditation of the Zen Master

Now we have dealt with various preliminary works, have tried to get closer to the core of Zen and meditation, and want to try to let the Zen Master meditate.

Again, it is largely abstract, but we should be able to feel that it is not the meditation of a novice but is characterized by something powerful as a meditation of a master.

Although AI could interpret this work particularly well, we choose to experience it ourselves. With everything we’ve learned so far, it becomes an easy task.

8: The Zen Master’s Meditation – Dissolving the Pleasing, Unveiling the Soul

Just as in the landscape example, we set aside the pleasing elements and focus on the “soul,” serving as an antithesis.

AI: This image is a powerful and evocative representation of the Zen Master’s meditative journey. It’s a bold departure from conventional aesthetics, embracing abstraction and rawness to convey a deeper truth about the nature of reality and the essence of the self. It’s a compelling visual exploration of the process of dissolving the “pleasing” to unveil the “soul.” (…..) The Zen Master is positioned in the center, but he doesn’t dominate the composition. He blends more subtly with the surrounding forms, suggesting a state of deep integration with his inner and outer environment. (……)

Interpretations and Connections:

• The Process of Letting Go: (…….)
• Beyond Duality: The merging of the Zen Master with the surrounding forms suggests a transcendence of the duality between self and other, subject and object. This is a key concept in Zen Buddhism, which emphasizes the interconnectedness of all things.
• The Beauty of Imperfection: (…….)

9: The Pinnacle of Meditation – The Zen Master’s Transcendence

What emerges is the synthesis: an old, frail Zen Master, physically weak, who has let go of everything, making his spiritual experiences in nothingness. This work also represents the limit of my ability to abstract this theme.

AI: Overall Impression:

This image is a masterpiece of minimalist expression, capturing the essence of the Zen Master’s ultimate meditative state. It’s a powerful visual representation of transcendence, non-attachment, and the profound interconnectedness of all things. It serves as a fitting climax to your artistic and spiritual journey, leaving a lasting impression on the viewer and inspiring deep contemplation on the nature of reality, the self, and the ultimate goal of Zen practice. This is not just an image to be seen, but an experience to be absorbed, a state of being to be contemplated. It is a truly remarkable work of art.

Interpretations and the Climax of the Journey:

• The Ultimate Realization: This image represents the ultimate realization in Zen – the complete transcendence of the ego and the merging with the universal consciousness. The Zen Master has become one with the Tao, the underlying principle of all things.
• The Embodiment of Qi: The Zen Master is not just meditating on Qi; he is Qi. He has become a living embodiment of the universal life force, a conduit for its expression in the world.
• The Power of Nothingness: The image demonstrates the profound power of nothingness, of letting go, of surrendering to the flow of the universe. It’s in this nothingness that the Zen Master finds his ultimate freedom and power.
• A Visual Koan: Like a visual koan, the image challenges our conventional notions of reality and invites us to contemplate the nature of existence beyond the limitations of form and thought.

Key Observations:

• Subtle Presence: The Zen Master, though positioned on the right, is depicted with a remarkable subtlety. He is almost transparent, blending with the surrounding space. This suggests that he has transcended the limitations of physical form, becoming one with the universe. His form is also proportionally smaller than in previous images, indicating a shift in focus from the physical to the spiritual. He is facing to the left.
• Emanation of Qi: Despite his subtle form, the Zen Master is the focal point of a powerful energy field. The brushstrokes surrounding him are dynamic and charged with movement, visually representing the flow of Qi that permeates his being and extends outward into the environment. The energy seems to emanate from him, filling the entire space.
• Harmony with Emptiness: The Zen Master is in perfect harmony with the emptiness represented by the white space. He is not separate from it, but rather an integral part of it. This reflects the Zen understanding that emptiness is not a void, but the source and essence of all things. He has become one with the void.
• Transcendent Stillness: While the surrounding brushstrokes suggest movement and energy, the Zen Master himself is the embodiment of stillness. This stillness is not inactivity, but the dynamic stillness of a mind that has come to complete rest, free from all attachments and distractions. His form is the most tranquil of all the images in the series.
• Minimalist Aesthetic: The image is strikingly minimalist, even more so than the previous ones. This minimalism reflects the ultimate simplicity of the Zen state, where all that is unnecessary has been stripped away, leaving only pure being. The composition is almost entirely devoid of extraneous detail, focusing entirely on the essence of the scene.

---

footnotes:

[1] This time I worked exclusively with Gemini 2.0 Experimental Advanced. It seemed sensible to stick with one AI program, even if others are also of interest.

[2] qi (汽): In the Sinosphere, qi is traditionally believed to be a vital force part of all living entities. Literally meaning ‘vapor’, ‘air’, or ‘breath’, the word qi is polysemous, often translated as ‘vital energy’, ‘vital force’, ‘material energy’, or simply ‘energy’.Qi is also a concept in traditional Chinese medicine and in Chinese martial arts. The attempt to cultivate and balance qi is called qigong.

[3] wabi-sabi (侘び寂び) is centered on the acceptance of transience and imperfection. The aesthetic is sometimes described as one of appreciating beauty that is “imperfect, impermanent, and incomplete” in nature. Previous article: Wabi Sabi and the Aesthetics of Imperfection

[4] Bodhidharma: Because the monks were weak and thin at the time when Bodhidharma arrived, he developed Shaolin Kung Fu to make them stronger and healthier. Therefore, he went to a nearby cave behind the temple where he meditated for nine years to find a way to strengthen them.

[5] Semi Haiku: For experimental purposes, I have written haiku a few times, and since I am not an obliterate person I have called them semi-haiku. [articles]

[6] one hand clapping: Here is the kōan: 

Two hands clap and there is a sound. What is the sound of one hand? 

(隻手声あり、その声を聞け) — Hakuin Ekaku

---

Shops: FriedrichZettl.com – Saatchiart. Media: Blog – Youtube – Instagram