Every Picture Tells a Story

Chinese “Stories” from the Hinterland

Every picture tells a story, and that’s the main criterion I use to determine whether a painting or photograph is interesting or meaningless for me. Unlike many experts or professionals who delight in technical details, I focus on the narratives – or even spirit – behind the images.

While my last few articles were text-intensive, and since every picture tells a story, this article provides a more visual journey. In this article, we dive into the rich tapestry of Chinese minority people, captured in photographs from the hinterlands of northwest China, specifically Qinghai and the border area with Tibet, taken between 1979 and 1982. I have a good Chinese friend with whom I share similar interests and so we also shared many of our photos. Photos that nobody really liked back then. Well, that’s just how it is.

You might wonder why these photos aren’t technically better. Well, to avoid uncomfortable questions, the photos were developed in-house in China using equipment that was quite simple and outdated at the time. But as is often the case in life, everything has a positive side and perhaps it was precisely the poor conditions that gave the photos even more narrative flair and let each telling its own story from the Chinese hinterland.

Most of the photos show Tibetans (བོད་པ་) and Qiang (羌族).

Have fun looking through them and creating your own stories!

young Chinese minority ladies


Another article with old photos from China: Andy Warhol, a Corpse, Opium, and a Botched Tribunal. related: The Gift of the Green Snake


Explore more: Discover original works on FriedrichZettl.com or Saatchi Art

For more insights into my process, follow me on Instagram and YouTube

Comments

73 responses to “Every Picture Tells a Story”

  1. Milena Alien avatar

    Those pictures speak louder than a thousand words

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much, Milena 🙏🌷I am happy you like them. I took a lot of photos during my years in China but some of the b/w are my favourites. ❤️🌹🌞

      1. Milena Alien avatar

        They are really showing the country and its people

  2. Nancy's Notes 🖊️🎶 avatar

    Truer words were never spoken, Fred. These are exquisite, each one worthy of a novel. Truly beautiful photography!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much, dear Nancy! 🙏🌷No need to tell you that I miss those days. ❤️🌹☀️🥂

      1. Nancy's Notes 🖊️🎶 avatar

        No need, Fred. They speak what’s in your heart. Wonderful, beautiful memories. 💫💛✨

  3. Edith avatar

    Mir tut sich eine ganz andere Welt auf. Abgebildete Menschen, die ihre Gesichter sprechen lassen, dann erst folgt für mich das Umfeld. Sie leben dort, wo du sie getroffen hast, dort, wo wir es sicher nur mal für einige Zeit aushalten würden.
    Sie wirken nicht unglücklich, nur den Umständen angepasst.
    Danke, lieber Freund, für solche Einblicke, die uns zeigen, das WIR hier nicht der Mittelpunkt allen Lebens sind.
    Dir ganz herzlichliebe Grüße von mir.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Vielen Dank, liebe Edith! Ja, eine ganz andere Welt. Ich habe oft bewusst “aermlichere” Gegenden aufgesucht und natürlich wäre es mir nicht (mehr) möglich, dort länger zu leben. Aber ich darf Dir versichern, dass sich gerade diese Aufenthalte am tiefsten bei mir eingeprägt haben. Mein nächster Artikel wird daher etwas überraschend, denn er zeigt das absolute Gegenteil. Ich halte mich gerade dort auf und mehr verrate ich auch nicht 😎❤️🌹☀️

      1. Edith avatar

        Dann bist du quasi wieder auf Bildungsreise, lächel. Nur gut, du lässt uns an allem teilhaben, ich freue mich schon auf deine neu gewonnenen Eindrücke.
        Du Lieber, ja, sie wohnen und leben sicher ärmlich, doch ob sie sich ärmlich fühlen? Diese Menschen kennen nichts anderes. Und weißt du, woran mich dies alles beim Anschauen erinnert hat? Vergleichsweise an die Menschen in der DDR. Sie waren zufrieden, bis, ja, bis vielen der Besuch in den Westen gestattet wurde. Dann sahen sie anders, bunter, vielfältiger, billiger … Es ist ein schwacher Vergleich, ich weiß, doch meine Assoziation war so – kennt man nicht anders, ist man zufrieden, sieht man anderes, steigen Wünsche ….
        Friedrich, dir einen guten Aufenthalt, viele neue Eindrücke – und – komm gesund zurück. Ich jedenfalls warte hier, lächel…
        Herzlichst, Edith

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Liebe Edith, die Erfahrung und Weisheit des Alters 😎 Sie kennen nichts anderes und sind zufrieden, wenn ihnen niemand was anderes vormacht. Das karge Leben von Bergbauern , aber auch Stolz. Ich war versucht, mehr darüber zu schreiben, aber da kommt nichts Gutes dabei heraus. Wir im Westen verstehen so Vieles nicht, haben aber fixe Überzeugungen. Die wir oft schneller wechseln als die Leute dort ihre Wäsche.
        Mein Aufenthalt jetzt ist als solches nicht von Interesse – nur als Kontrapunkt. LG f

      3. Edith avatar

        Ja, ich hatte den Stolz vergessen … und ich verstehe dich, es wird schnell geurteilt, obwohl einem so gut wie NICHTS bekannt ist. Auch Kontrapunkte sind interessant, vielleicht, um den Blick schärfer zu machen. Ich freu mich drauf, auf das, was du zeigen wirst…
        Herzlichst, ich.

  4. Mike U. avatar

    Utterly fascinating. There’s such depth of character and humanity in each image, yet also a sense of a completely different world, a different time… Amazing work, Friedrich.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much, Mike🙏 I am not surprised you like them. Yes, A different world but I feel closer to it than to some big cities. 🌞🎶🥂

  5. Spira avatar

    ” I can’t imagine you won’t like them” you said to me through a comment.
    Friedrich, I am sorry but… you were wrong.
    I don’t like them.
    I absolutely love them.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thanks a bunch, Nick! There’s a lot of meaning in them, isn’t it? Enjoy a great weekend! ☀️🎶🥂

  6. Martina Ramsauer avatar

    These pictures are really very touching, Friedrich, and I must say that we didn’t meet this kind of poor people when we travelled in China about 20 years ago. Probably we weren’t close enough to Tibet! I thank you very much for these impressions.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much, Martina! 20 years ago things looked very different. Not to talk about today. The photos are 45 years old and the area was not open for foreigners. I don’t think many Chinese took photos then as it was considered meaningless to take photos of poor people. Enjoy a great weekend!

      1. Martina Ramsauer avatar

        Many thanks for your interesting answer!

  7. Stan Stewart avatar

    Amazing images. Yes, I have a few stories and inspirations from these. Thank you!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much, Stan! I am happy you like them. A world that has basically disappeared I guess.

  8. luisa zambrotta avatar

    Great post and fabulous photos 🩵🙏💙🙏🩵

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thanks a bunch, dear Luisa 🙏 I was sure you would like them ❣️🌹☀️🥂

      1. luisa zambrotta avatar

        You are so very welcome my dear friend.
        It was my pleasure as always

  9. wakasahs15th avatar

    Photos of Qinghai Province and Tibet from this period are extremely valuable. I went to China for the first time in 1985, and I remember seeing many people in Beijing and Shanghai who looked very similar to these people.
    I also think that there were very few foreigners like you living in China at that time. Thank you for the precious photos, dear Zettl Fine Arts

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏 You are absolutely right. I left Beijing in 1985. At that time we occasionally could see minority people in the streets. Everything changed so quickly. When I first visited Kunming I saw a peasant with his pig in a main street. Now there are only skyscrapers 😃

      1. Martha Kennedy avatar

        In my village in Guangdog the pigs wandered the streets picking up dropped food and whatever pig thing they wanted to eat. Water buffalo, too, though usually accompanied by a human. And, of course, chickens. Now it’s an elegant suburb. I wish I could have seen the places you did. https://photos.google.com/photo/AF1QipNsmkE4MelYmSAUiONZuOwWlIsRNyFlWQhfssWw

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Thank you, Martha, 🙏. Yes, so much has changed in such a short time. I am really happy I had the chance to travel there in an early time period.

  10. Misky avatar

    Friedrich, this one image, I will call it “The Smoker of Tibet,” is kissed by the processing tools of its time. It whispers tales of resilience etched onto his weathered face. The stark contrast evokes the harsh beauty of the Tibetan landscape, a place where survival is an art. His eyes, (his eyes!) are pools of ancient wisdom, hint at stories untold, while the cigarette becomes a fragile bridge between tradition and the relentless march of time. There is a profound dignity in his stance, a quiet defiance against the elements, making you feel both humbled and connected to his enduring spirit. I can almost hear the wind carrying his secrets across the vast, unforgiving plains. This is a person I’d love to invite for dinner.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much, Misky 🙏 You are a true poet with wise eyes. I met a few people like him and had a similar feeling like you. And I thought much about my interpretation. What is fact and what my imagination. But no matter what it was, the fascination was real. Enjoy a great weekend 🌹☀️🎶

  11. David Milligan-Croft avatar

    Stunning! I love them. What an incredibly important historical archive. On a side note, in some of the images, the people have an almost Native American appearance. (Or, vice versa.) You can see how these people once migrated across the land bridge between what is now Russia/Alaska, then gradually moved south.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much, David! 🙏 Yes, there always was much more migration than some semi-blondes think. In Ming Dynasty China had the strongest fleet one could imagine. Even in the Song Dynasty (around 1100) they visited Angkor. And the land bridge.

  12. TracySchruder avatar

    Thank you for sharing such an amazing post! So much can be said about these photographs. Great work!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much from the bottom of my heart ❤️ I am glad you enjoyed the photos 🙏🌹☀️

  13. Ashley avatar

    Amazing, remarkable photos! How does it make you feel, looking back at these snapshots from “another” world? Were you as cold as these folk look? What did they think about you, I wonder! Were you able to talk to them? I’m sure you have MANY stories!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you Ashley! By that time I had rather long hair and a beard. While many people back home had problems with my appearance I noticed more tolerance in rural areas. I was often stared at in Beijing though. Yes, many stories and not all suitable for sharing 🤣 Communication basically worked well. I don’t understand dialects but most of us know putonghua – standard Chinese.

      1. Ashley avatar

        Enjoy the rest of the weekend 🙏

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Thank you, I will. And when you read my next article you will understand why 😎

  14. julianeus avatar

    Yes! It’s like a time stopped. I don’t like people’s sorrow, and on that pictures there are so munch pain. But, they are a great antique pictures. 🙂

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏 Yes, like time stopped……But it sure is different today.

  15. Rosaliene Bacchus avatar

    Fascinating images, Friedrich! I feel the cold. It would be interesting to see how much life has changed for them since 1982.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you, Rosaliene 🙏 I first thought of adding some info on minorities in China. It’s a difficult topic with high chances to misunderstand. Yes, sure a lot has changed.

  16. dancinglightofgrace avatar

    These pictures speak louder than a 100 rupees note.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏 What a coincidence: just now I had rupee notes in my hand incl a 100 rupee note – no joke 🤣

  17. swabby429 avatar

    Technically “perfect” photography has its place in media and art, but so do urban and unplanned photography. Snapshots and candid pictures are more vital and feel more authentic than painstakingly crafted photographs. To be clear, I love both ends of the spectrum and everything in between.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      You are right and I see it the same. But sometimes I regret I didn’t learn more than the basics.

      1. swabby429 avatar

        People have different priorities at various stages of our lives and careers. I am becoming more interested in photography again, and am doing plenty of catching-up. This is a pleasant part of the journey.

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Great 👍 Good luck. It’s always a good idea to try something new or improve.

      3. swabby429 avatar

        Thank you. I’m having some fun with trying out new techniques and discovering new subjects to photograph.

  18. graysummers avatar

    Fantastic collection Friedrich. Black and white film captures, taken in specific periods as these are, become iconic. You simply cannot reproduce the vibe of film with such imagery. These remind me of Sebastiao Salgado’s and W. Eugene Smith’s black and white images of people, in that they are now timeless and precious captures. Each person here holds fascination for the viewer. Thank you for sharing.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much, Gray, for your always kind words and support 🙏 I am happy you like the images. 🌹🎶🌻

      1. graysummers avatar

        They are fine captures Friedrich. 🙏🏽

  19. Chen Song Ping avatar

    Looks like winter wears! Although not furry type!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you! Yes, cold in winter, strong sun in summer.

  20. Carolyn Kaiser Harmon avatar

    So much texture, Friedrich! The fringe, fur, and layers of clothing, lack of teeth, shadows, wrinkles in the skin, expressions – a tapestry of living. Like Misky, I too am enchanted with “The Smoker of Tibet,” and am especially attracted to the composition of the third image with the open door and dramatic lights and darks. Fabulous work as always❤️.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      You are very kind, Carolyn, and I thank you from the Button of my heart 🙏. Yes, as you see it correctly, a tapestry of living. A tapestry that allows reflections. Thanks and love 🌷🌹❤️

  21. myrelar avatar

    ❤️ 💖

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      ❤️ 💖

  22. rabirius avatar

    Really wonderful pictures!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏☀️🌻

  23. Priti avatar

    Wonderful photography 😊

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏☀️🌻

      1. Priti avatar

        👏

  24. Copper coated highways avatar

    Amazing photos.

  25. […] This article should have been a trivial one, serving as a yin-yang example. The yang part is my last article on Chinese minority peoples. The photos show their meager life and poor living conditions in the mountain regions. They also […]

  26. Copper coated highways avatar

    Excellent photographs

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much!

  27. wholelottarosie avatar

    Lieber Friedrich, da bringst du einen wichtigen Punkt zur Sprache, der oft in der Diskussion über Kunst und Fotografie übersehen wird – nämlich die narrative Dimension von Bildern. Während technische Aspekte wie Komposition, Lichtführung oder Farbwahl zweifellos eine Rolle spielen, ist es für mich immer die Geschichte, die ein Bild erzählt, und die es für mich wirklich bedeutungsvoll macht. Diese Perspektive erinnert mich daran, dass Kunst nicht nur aus handwerklichem Können besteht, sondern auch aus Emotionen und Erfahrungen, die sie vermittelt.
    Denn sind es nicht letztlich die Geschichten – sei es eine persönliche Erinnerung oder eine universelle menschliche Erfahrung – die uns verbinden und uns dazu bringen, innezuhalten und nachzudenken?
    Deine Fotos sind so wunderbar, berühren mein Herz, lassen mich innehalten und entfachen immer wieder eine Gänsehaut.
    Großartig!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Vielen herzliches Dank, liebe Rosie! Es freut mich sehr, dass Dir die Photos gefallen 🙏 Es ist eine andere Welt….🌹☀️🎶

  28. worldphoto12 avatar

    BUON WEEKEND

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you! The same to you ☀️🎶😃

      1. worldphoto12 avatar

        😃👍👏🙋‍♀️

  29. 1020sdf510 avatar
    1020sdf510

    grand! 109Goodbye to the Winter

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much!

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Friedrich Zettl

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading