seal blog post image

Delving into the Realm of Seals on Artwork

yes, those little red spots.

Delving into the Realm of Seals on Artwork – or just for seals for fun. Since I have been asked about it repeatedly, I would like to go into it in more detail today and share my personal insights into this captivating art form.

Delving into the realm of seals in artwork isn’t just a scholarly pursuit—it’s a vibrant exploration that many find fascinating, especially those with a keen interest in Southeast Asian art.

Seals hold a special place in my life, and I’ve touched on their significance in a previous article about Chinese seals. The world of seal engraving is vast, encompassing historical importance, the intricate art of seal carving—from design to technique—and the diverse materials used by collectors. It’s no wonder that Chinese seals have become highly sought after, commanding seven figure results at auctions.

The rise and fall of a seal cutter – me

But today, I’m sharing a more intimate aspect of my journey with seal engraving, a craft that has long captivated my heart. My fascination began over five decades ago with a book about a Zen calligrapher. One line struck a chord and has resonated with me ever since: “A calligrapher might finish their work in minutes, yet they spend twenty minutes finding the perfect spot for their seal.” This insight was my first direct encounter with the art of seals, and it remains a profound observation.

My inaugural trip to China in 1978 led me straight to a seal stone shop, far removed from the tourist trinkets of today. That initial visit sparked a collection that grew to 2,000+ seals over the years, many of which I’ve since sold, with the core collection now residing in a Chinese museum. Reflecting on this brings a nostalgic tear to my eye. Of the 20 or so trips I made to China over the years, I financed quite a few of them through trading in seals. A fortnight in Shanghai, exploring shops and markets, and acquiring a bunch of seals, I could finance the entire adventure.

After I discovered the subject of seals, it didn’t take long before I started carving seals myself, initially for my artwork. The enthusiasm from my Chinese friends was encouraging, and in July 1983, a prestigious Japanese magazine featured an article about my work, complete with photos of my seals. I sure felt some pride, particularly as I was, to my knowledge, the first non-Asian to grace the pages of this esteemed publication that continues to thrive.

zettl seals in Japanese magazine
新書鑑 (Mirror of new books), Kobe 1983

The seal artist Wáng Yōng 王鏞

The following also seems remarkable to me: My quest for mastery in seal cutting led me to seek a mentor during my stay at the academy in Beijing. Among all, only one postgraduate student, Wáng Yōng, shared my enthusiasm for seals and possessed the skill to carve them. It was heartening to discover that he is now a rightly recognized artist. (baidu article)

The admiration of my Chinese friends and mentors was not always mere courtesy and recognition of my dedication. My passion for seal engraving was not mere fascination; it was an intense pursuit that led to a knowledge and understanding that they found remarkable. To illustrate this, I would like to show a seal of Wáng Yōng – the one on the top left in the attached image.

First of all, it should be said that hardly any Chinese can decipher seal script. The inscription reads: 銅石心腸 (tóng shí xīn cháng) copper – stone – heart – intestine

This doesn’t make sense if you don’t know that there was a movement, a renaissance during the Ming Dynasty when artists sought inspiration from the inscriptions on ancient bronzes and stone stele engravings to elevate their craft—a practice that resonates with me profoundly.

So the meaning of seal in question goes: “Bronzes and stones are my destiny.” This phrase encapsulates more than just a preference; it signifies a deep-seated affinity, an intention, and a reflection of one’s innermost inclinations and state of mind. For me, this ‘bronze and stone sentiment’ has woven itself into the fabric of my being, influencing my artistic journey and personal identity.

wang yong seals

Little An (xiǎo ān (小安), an exceptional seal carver

My second visit to China introduced me to Xiao An [1], a young woman with whom I shared countless hours discussing the intricate art of seal cutting. My passion ignited her curiosity, and soon, I was teaching her the challenging craft. Her initial attempts were astonishing, leaving me utterly speechless. As she progressed, each seal surpassed the last in craftsmanship.

The end result was that I stopped cutting seals. Not out of envy or jealousy, on the contrary, I was happy for her, but I realized that I was far too traditional and I had no idea how to get to a higher level, I was simply middle class at best. She specialized in picture seals, a genre that has existed in China for over 3,000 years. [2]

seals be di an
seals by di an

The Seal Carver and Calligrapher Cheng Yutian 程与天

Wang Yong, discussed above, was an extremely nice colleague, showed me his treasures, diligently printed his new seals in my seal book – and above all he introduced me to a very remarkable artist: Cheng Yutian. Yutian and I spent a lot of time together. Chinese colleagues at the time could hardly do anything with his work and he was all the more honored by the admiration of a foreigner 😊. I probably have the largest collection of Cheng Yutian’s seal impressions ever. Like Wang Yong he is a well-known artist today.

Yutian’s journey to becoming a calligrapher is as extraordinary as his art. During the Cultural Revolution, he was a construction worker, a job that left little room for artistic pursuits. Brushes, ink, and paper were luxuries beyond his reach. Yet, his passion for calligraphy didn’t wane. Each evening, after the day’s labor, he would practice his strokes using a bricklayer’s brush and the cement residue from washed buckets, turning construction formwork boards into his canvas. This dedication continued for years.

When our paths crossed, Yutian had just completed a seal for Zhuo Lin, the widow of Deng Xiaoping, and had dispatched it to her. His story is a testament to the indomitable spirit of creativity that thrives against all odds.

cheng yutian seals

The swan song of my seal carving

If I’m not mistaken, these are the last 3 seals I cut (image below). Left: name seal for a Chinese friend. Middle: “A window full of sun” (一窗清日 yī chuāng qīng rì). And the right one? “Little An”. I had planned to give Xiao An a seal as a token of my appreciation. But when we met, she surprised me with a seal she had made herself for me. Its beauty was so great that I found my own gift pale in comparison, and I decided not to reveal it. To this day, the seal remains wrapped, a silent testament to the talent that overshadowed it. But with time and distance, it has regained some of its appeal for me. While it cannot compare to Xiao An’s masterpiece, it has a charm all its own.

3 seals by Friedrich Zettl
seals for artwork

extra:

In the following section you will find a curated selection of images that bring the theme of seals to life. Seals are not just about the engravings. The stones themselves are also treasures coveted by collectors. The image of the stone drum, which comes from an online community (quora), shows the raw beauty of this genre. The other images show seals that were once or still are part of my personal collection, each with its own story and meaning.

inscription on Chinese stone drum 3000+ years old
han dynasty seal
my Han Dynasty seal c. 400 BC
seal collection
Selection of stone seals. Result of a shopping trip to Shanghai (part)
tianhuang_seal
seal made of Tian Huang stone, the most expensive stone for seals.
carved chickenblood stone
My favorite chicken blood stone. The more red, the more valuable it is.
footnotes

[1] I don’t want to use her real name as I didn’t ask for the OK, but I think she would be happy to see her seals shown to a wider audience. I’m afraid she never understood how great her seals are and stopped cutting seals soon after we returned from China.

[2] There are authorities seals, name seals, studio seals, leasure seals, collector seals. Recommended: Wikipedia article on seals


Similar articles can be found in my section Art Theory

Shops: FriedrichZettl.comSaatchiart . Media: Blog YoutubeInstagram


by

Tags:

Comments

61 responses to “Delving into the Realm of Seals on Artwork”

  1. gary j avatar

    Just absolute thanks and respect for sharing this. greetings from oz dear Friedrich. gary j

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      I have to thank you, Gary! Vienna greets Oz! f

  2. J M Negi avatar

    so painstaking post indeed, thanks.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      You are so very kind! Thankfully yours 🙂

  3. Gerda avatar
    Gerda

    Very interesting, thank you

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you, Gerda! It’s a very specific subject area and probably not many readers will be able to relate to it. On the other hand, it’s a fascinating world that opens up. So I wanted to introduce it.

  4. Himanshi Dargas avatar

    Perfect post..

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      You are very kind, thank you so much!

  5. swabby429 avatar

    I’ve often pondered seals on calligraphy and on the bottoms of pottery. I never knew they are a genre upon themselves.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Oh yes! The seals on old porcelain usually indicate under which emperor it was created. On ceramic vessels they usually refer to the studio or the potter himself. BTW This helps the collector to distinguish whether he is holding a genuine piece or a fake. A world of it’s own 🙂

      1. swabby429 avatar

        Thank you for the clarification.

  6. rabirius avatar

    The seals look really amazing. So unlike the European ones that I know. Also the background you give is very interesting.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much! Yes, it is a quite different approach. Especially since seal carving is an own high rated form of art and needs lots of practice.

  7. Stan Stewart avatar

    I’m especially impressed with two things in this post (and almost every post I’ve ever read from you): your level of knowledge and your honoring of the people who have been your mentors and inspirations.
    Thank you for your artistry.
    Stan

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much, Stan! I am very happy about your kind words. In fact we all learn from each other. I had the great opportunity to meet incredibly good artists in my years in China and as everyone was very poor those then we could concentrate on our work. And of course I learnt more from my Chinese friends than I realised then. Stay well! Friedrich

  8. Rosaliene Bacchus avatar

    Friedrich, thanks for the introduction to the Chinese art of seal engraving 🙂 Yet another fascinating topic. I found the story of Cheng Yutian, a construction worker, of special interest. Though our situation may seem hopeless, we already have what we need to pursue/achieve our dreams/goals.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you, Rosaliene! Yes, it’s a tough time for many people, I know. It’s a big topic with many facets and too many different interest groups. That’s why it’s very difficult to address this topic. But many are starting to think about aspects that weren’t an issue just a few years ago. So let’s hope that we can get out of this impasse soon and, above all, make things better.

  9. graysummers avatar

    Fascinating. Thank you for this insightful information. Enjoyed this very much. All the best.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thanks a lot! I’m pleased to see that this special topic has been well received. Greetings from Vienna!

      1. graysummers avatar

        Greetings too from Wales.

  10. Martha Kennedy avatar

    Fascinating! Thank you, Friedrich. These were carved by a man I met in an art shop in the Fragrant Hills. He and the man who’d done the calligraphy had been in the 8th Route Army. I spent most of a day with them. The happiest of many happy hours I lived in China. I can’t comment to the quality of the carving, only to the love and passion this man had for this art and the treasure this piece of rice paper is in my life. https://marthakennedy.files.wordpress.com/2024/05/img_4625.jpg

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much Martha! You have a very attractive collection. Some of your seals are cut after 3000 year old models.

      How privileged we were back then to get to know so many extremely fascinating people! And everyone was modest and hardly anyone put on a show for themselves. Instead, they worked persistently, day after day, quietly and calmly to improve themselves. At least in the circle I was in.

      1. Martha Kennedy avatar

        It was the same with the people I knew. We were very lucky to be in China when we were.

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Definitely! Quite a few of my colleagues at the academy seemed innocent like little kids – in the best meaning. And all very diligent.

      3. Martha Kennedy avatar

        The two men in the art shop in were open about that. My Chinese teacher (a professor at Beijing Technological Institute who’d studied a couple years in Denver) was with us. He took me there so I had a great translator who knew me. Both of the artists said they dreamed of that art shop through the war and the cultural revolution and never imagined it would be real. It kept them positive and moving forward. I tried very hard to imagine being artists — which both men were — and instead of that trudging through terror which they had done for years. Everything in their shop (which they’d rebuilt after the Cultural Revolution) was beautiful and beloved. Now I know it also said, “We didn’t die!” I think you’re right; there was that innocence of wonder maybe because of that? Ma Yue (the seal carver) and I corresponded for years.

      4. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        When the nightmare is over, the big awakening comes. It must have been hell for intellectuals and I admire everyone who came through it unscathed. A good friend of mine told me at the time that her grandfather, an elderly, recognized artist, had not noticed the Cultural Revolution. His family set up a small room for him in which he could work – and that was all he needed.

      5. Martha Kennedy avatar

        I think being imprisoned, tortured, all of that, for just being who you are? I also think true freedom is just that; the space to be who you are. That artist had a brave good family.

        In March I was out at the Refuge. A car stopped and a young man rolled down the window. He asked — in a Beijing accent — “Can you tell me where I might find the Sandhill Cranes?” I was stunned. I told him they were mostly gone and asked if he were Chinese. We spoke some Puntungwah and he asked if I would return to China. Before we said good-bye he rolled down all the windows. Three generations were in that car. The old mother’s eyes met mine and in our eye contact everything about that lost world. I have not felt that level of comprehension very often in my life. The young man is a professor at a university in Denver. I didn’t ask which. I wasn’t a Sandhill Crane, but still a pretty rare bird in that remote place.

      6. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Thank you, Martha, for this touching story! Yes, we all know too little about others if we don’t leave our four walls and – above all – the dictates of our opinions.

  11. Spira avatar

    What a generous offering of a big part of your artistic & personal journey this post is, Friedrich; thank you.
    Seals are magnificent objects and I have always being fascinated by them.
    The one I have, from Lijiang, is a treasured item ( half written in mandarin, half in Naxi).

    I could not but have a wide smile upon reading the line about the time needed to find the perfect spot for the seal.

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thanks again Nick! Your seal is missing in my collection 🙂 Yes, these bilingual seals have their own special charm. I have some with Mongolian and Chinese characters.

      Yes, the right place for the seal on a work can make or break it. (Similar to putting on a lady’s makeup 🙂 ).

  12. 6qsite avatar

    Sehr, sehr interessant!!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Vielen herzlichen Dank! Ich bin überrascht, dass dieser Artikel gut ankommt, da es doch um ein Randthema geht. LG f

      1. 6qsite avatar

        Anscheinend brauchten wir viele von uns, die qualitativ hochwertige Informationen wie die Ihre über die “mysteriösen” Briefmarken brauchten, die in der Regel die Kunstwerke des Fernen Ostens begleiten. Danke, dass Sie es uns zur Verfügung gestellt haben.

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Eines der großen Geschenke unserer Zeit ist, dass wir uns global austauschen können. Wir können das mit positiven Themen, die unseren Horizont erweitern, tun – wie mit negativen, einengenden Themen. Alles Gute!

      3. 6qsite avatar

        👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  13. Digital Empire avatar

    Wooow! There is so much information packed in here. It’s so interesting!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏 I am happy you like it. If I start to talk about seals there is no end…. 😂

  14. Raymond Chuang avatar

    Gave a circular seal to my theremin teacher in Germany with her name in letters instead of Chinese characters. She loved it!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Great! I gave self cut seals to some Western friends and yes, they really liked them. And kept them as gems 🤣㊗️🙏

  15. Desmond R. avatar

    Your journey with seal engraving sounds fascinating! It’s amazing how a simple line from a book can spark a lifelong passion. -ArConsultings.org

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much! Yes, it is fascinating why we develop “loves” that fascinate us throughout our lives.

  16. Ashley avatar

    Friedrich, this post, dare I say it, is for me one of your finest! I’m bowled over by your knowledge & skill in painting & calligraphy but with regard to seals I’m blown away! I have always felt huge emotion for anything to do with art & for CRAFT, & seal making must surely be the greatest of those endeavours! I’m spellbound by the picture seals, they are amazing! Friedrich, I can’t thank you enough for your posts! I feel like a different person having read this post. Thank you for opening windows & for sharing your passion for the arts, crafts & for life. 🙏😊🙋‍♂️

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Oh Ashley, I am overwhelmed by your enthusiasm and am blushing at your praise! Picture seals are of course the easiest for Westerners to understand, but these are also among the most beautiful that I know.

      Perhaps I should write a post on arts&craft sometime. I have of course collected some nice old Chinese objects over the years. But also some small treasures from other cultures. It will take some time though as I have some other articles planned. There are some beautiful things happening right now.

      1. Ashley avatar

        For me right now, the most beautiful thing is being outside again in the garden. My body aches as I’ve done too much today in our tiny garden, getting it ready for summer. Again, thank you, Friedrich for your energising posts.

      2. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

        Oh, how I know this! A day of work in the garden and 3 days to recover. Good luck and thanks, Ashley !

  17. Cindy Georgakas avatar

    You blow me away, Friedrich with your love and passion for diving in and presenting us with such a feast for the heart and eyes. I love seals and carvings and have a few but never have I thought about the extensive meaning, time it takes to carve and research behind the scenes. What a lovely gift to receive and to have waiting in this paper as a memory. I best she would sooooo much appreciate this gift as a token of your time together and friendship and hey, now that she’s not carving you don’t have to worry about it “not measuring up to hers”. Remember, it’s the thought and random act of kindness it represents. I’m certain she would be over the moon with this post and seeing her work. I adore both yours and hers!!! 💓💕

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you, dear Cindy, for your very kind words! It’s obvious that you’ve gained new energy on holiday!

      I am pleasantly surprised that so many people liked this marginal topic. I will post something about it again at some point to present further aspects. For me it has always been a pleasure to immerse myself in other worlds – physical or intellectual. Best regards from Vienna! 💓💕

      1. Cindy Georgakas avatar

        It’s my pleasure, Friedrich. So true, I did come back renewed. Now I best be careful before I use all that renewal up again. lol!😉
        It was a spectacular topic with your essence and love shinning through in every word and stamp. Cheers my friend💕💓💕

  18. Luna avatar
    Luna

    Thanks for sharing… these are so beautiful

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      I thank you for your interest and reading 🙏☀️🎶

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much 🙏

  19. myrelar avatar

    Very nice post!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      many thanks!

  20. spotlightchoices.com-C. Wilson avatar

    Thanks for your background information for this art style!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you so much! You are welcome 🙏☀️🌼

  21. Chen Song Ping avatar

    Interesting, you even did seals! I was once so proud of my Chinese paintings, although I was only an amateur that I even had a seal made for myself!

    1. Zettl Fine Arts avatar

      Thank you very much! Yes, you need your own seal. Cutting seals is very fascinating and for some time now I have been keen to cut one again. But above all I was a collector – and then I traded them. I had well over 1000 seals and many of them were from important seal cutters. It is a world of its own.

      1. Chen Song Ping avatar

        Wow!

  22. […] etymological root of abundance,Delving into the Realm of Seals on Artwork (yì), is the image of a vessel whose contents are breaking its boundaries. This powerful metaphor […]

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Friedrich Zettl

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading